ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Intersectionality in Conservative Movements: How (upper) Class Stratification shapes Minority Alliances and Collective Identities

Elites
Identity
Race
Activism
Samina Mesgarzadeh
Université de Lausanne
Samina Mesgarzadeh
Université de Lausanne

Abstract

While intersectionality is a concept rooted in progressive movements and linked to groups that face multiple oppressions, I propose to focus on the « intersectional performances » (Jaunait & Chauvin, 2012) of French upper class minorities that created various elite clubs in Paris since the mid 2000s. Drawing on an ethnographic fieldwork (71 interviews, participant observation, documents) conducted in three clubs, I will tackle two main questions. First, I will reflect upon the discourse of « diversity » (Bereni, 2009) promoted by employers’ organisations and right-wing politicians. As a managerial reformulation of anti-discrimination at the workplace, this discourse does not result in a debate concerning the inclusion of minorities in employers’ organisations or upper class clubs, nor does it transform the French ideology of « indifference to difference » (Escafré-Dublet & Simon, 2009) at a larger scale (as shown by the current controversies about the organisation of « nonmixt » -i.e. racialized only-workshops in French trade unions). However, I will show that this discourse created a targeted political opportunity for upper class minorities. No longer depending on the historical link between « immigrant » organisations and the left-wing, upper class minorities can try to use as a resource their positions as minority and upper class members. Second, drawing on a relational approach and the notion of « field » (Bourdieu, 1992), I will examine the identities and alliances that are displayed by the three clubs. I will show that upper class stratification and the connections that these clubs have (or not) with political and administrative spheres can account for their « identity strategies » - « celebration » or « suppression » of difference (Bernstein, 1997)- as well as for the publicisation or not of the links and alliances they have with immigrant associations.